Top Plastic Surgeon Reviews

The ONLY Super-Review Website for Plastic Surgeons

Male abs
Bleph pre-post
Seal
Brow-face incision
Shhhh
Male abs
Bleph pre-post
Seal

The Southwest Florida Coast, including Bradenton, Sarasota, Naples, Fort Myers, and surrounding areas

Plastic Surgeons Ranked in Order of
Their Ratings and Reviews (Summary)

All Ratings Above 4 (Out of 5 Stars)
Rank Plastic Surgeon Total
1 Jeffrey K. Scott, MD 1906
2 Joshua Kreithen, MD 1676
3 Kent V. Hasen, MD 1459
4 Robert J. Brueck, MD 1412
5 Brian M. Derby, MD 1176
6 Michael K. Kim, MD 964
7 Scott J. Engel, MD 939
8 Manuel Pena, MD 885
9 Elizabeth L. Fox, MD 775
10 Marguerite Barnett, MD 774
11 Kiranjeet Gill, MD 685
12 Audrey E. Farahmand, MD 504
13 Paul M. Gardner, MD 478
14 Andrew Turk, MD 438
15 Nalin Master, MD 396
16 William A. Ross, MD 395
17 Andrea Basile, MD 390
18 Alissa M. Shulman, MD 383
19 Alex Senchenkov, MD 371
20 Lorraine M. Golosow, MD 370
21 Christopher G. Constance, MD 371
22 Mark F. Prysi, MD 314
23 Michael Van Vliet, MD 287
24 William S. Wittenborn, MD 268
25 Charles L. Rodriguez, MD 213
26 F. Nicholas N. Gahhos, MD 205
27 Issa Baroudi, MD 171
28 Robert G. Chami, MD 149
29 Mark E. Mathieson, MD 126
30 Braun H. Graham, MD 100
31 Leopoldo M. Baccaro, MD 60
32 J Ryan Jackson, MD 58
Some Ratings Between 3-4 (Out of 5 Stars)
Rank Plastic Surgeon Total
33 Marc S. Schneider, MD 799
34 Melinda Lacerna, MD 762
35 James W. Marsh, MD 762
36 Ronaldo Carneiro, MD 566
37 Joseph Mazza, MD 483
38 John D. Ritrosky, MD 185
Some Ratings Below 3 (Out of 5 Stars)
Rank Plastic Surgeon Total
39 Ralph R. Garramone, MD 1782
40 Orlando Cicilioni, MD 556
41 Rebecca L. Crane, MD 183
42 Robert V. Mandraccia, MD 147
43 William O. Murtagh, MD 31

Detailed Ratings and Reviews

→ Entire Table Scrolls Right to Show Details. →
Plastic Surgeons with All Ratings Above 4 (Out of 5 Stars)
Rank Total score Plastic Surgeon Office Location Vitals Healthgrades Realself Google Grand Total
Score # Total Score # Total Score # Total Score # Total
1 1906 Jeffrey K. Scott, MD Bradenton 4.8 149 715 4.8 133 638 5.0 86 430 4.9 25 123 1906
2 1676 Joshua Kreithen, MD Sarasota 4.5 63 284 4.5 48 216 4.8 78 374 4.8 167 802 1676
3 1459 Kent V. Hasen, MD Naples 4.6 58 267 4.6 39 179 4.8 119 571 4.7 94 442 1459
4 1412 Robert J. Brueck, MD Fort Myers 4.7 45 212 4.6 53 244 4.9 110 539 4.8 87 418 1412
5 1176 Brian M. Derby, MD Sarasota 4.6 10 46 5.0 81 405 5.0 145 725 1176
6 964 Michael K. Kim, MD Fort Myers 4.8 51 245 4.9 90 441 4.7 17 80 4.6 43 198 964
7 939 Scott J. Engel, MD Sarasota 4.5 31 140 4.9 27 132 5.0 104 520 4.9 30 147 939
8 885 Manuel Pena, MD Naples 4.8 25 120 4.8 39 187 4.6 19 87 5.0 98 490 885
9 775 Elizabeth L. Fox, MD Naples 4.0 5 20 4.0 159 636 4.4 27 119 775
10 774 Marguerite Barnett, MD Sarasota 4.3 100 430 4.0 33 132 4.5 22 99 4.5 25 113 774
11 685 Kiranjeet Gill, MD Naples 4.0 8 32 4.8 34 163 5.0 24 120 5.0 74 370 685
12 504 Audrey E. Farahmand, MD Fort Myers 4.1 27 111 4.6 20 92 4.7 23 108 4.3 45 194 504
13 478 Paul M. Gardner, MD Naples 4.0 43 172 4.6 36 166 4.8 23 110 5.0 6 30 478
14 438 Andrew Turk, MD Naples 4.7 23 108 5.0 17 85 4.8 51 245 438
15 396 Nalin Master, MD Naples 4.7 35 165 4.9 39 191 5.0 5 25 5.0 3 15 396
16 395 William A. Ross, MD Naples 4.6 11 51 5.0 2 10 5.0 15 75 4.9 53 260 395
17 390 Andrea Basile, MD Naples 4.5 32 144 4.9 36 176 5.0 13 65 5.0 1 5 390
18 383 Alissa M. Shulman, MD Sarasota 4.0 24 96 4.9 33 162 5.0 3 15 4.8 23 110 383
19 371 Alex Senchenkov, MD Sarasota 4.0 35 140 4.2 20 84 5.0 3 15 4.9 27 132 371
20 370 Lorraine M. Golosow, MD Fort Myers 4.7 29 136 4.5 25 113 5.0 6 30 4.8 19 91 370
21 371 Christopher G. Constance, MD Port Charlotte 4.7 40 188 4.3 28 120 5.0 1 5 4.1 14 57 371
22 314 Mark F. Prysi, MD Naples 4.6 9 41 4.7 41 193 4.6 12 55 5.0 5 25 314
23 287 Michael Van Vliet, MD Lakewood Ranch 4.4 26 114 4.6 34 156 4.0 4 16 287
24 268 William S. Wittenborn, MD Fort Myers 4.1 15 62 4.5 35 158 5.0 5 25 4.8 5 24 268
25 213 Charles L. Rodriguez, MD Venice 4.5 24 108 4.6 12 55 5.0 10 50 213
26 205 F. Nicholas N. Gahhos, MD Venice 4.3 6 26 4.8 31 149 5.0 6 30 205
27 171 Issa Baroudi, MD Port Charlotte 4.5 30 135 4.5 8 36 171
28 149 Robert G. Chami, MD Naples 4.9 14 69 5.0 6 30 5.0 10 50 149
29 126 Mark E. Mathieson, MD Sarasota 4.2 11 46 5.0 16 80 126
30 100 Braun H. Graham, MD Sarasota 4.8 6 29 4.4 7 31 5.0 5 25 5.0 3 15 100
31 60 Leopoldo M. Baccaro, MD Naples 5.0 1 5 5.0 11 55 60
32 58 J Ryan Jackson, MD Naples 4.7 7 33 5.0 5 25 58
→ Entire Table Scrolls Right to Show Details. →
Plastic Surgeons with Some Ratings Between 3-4 (Out of 5 Stars)
Rank Total score Plastic Surgeon Office Location Vitals Healthgrades Realself Google Grand Total
Score # Total Score # Total Score # Total Score # Total
33 799 Marc S. Schneider, MD Fort Myers 3.9 25 98 4.0 25 100 4.7 49 230 4.7 79 371 799
34 762 Melinda Lacerna, MD Sarasota 3.7 36 133 3.9 54 211 4.6 91 419 762
35 762 James W. Marsh, MD Sarasota 3.8 21 80 4.9 133 652 5.0 6 30 762
36 566 Ronaldo Carneiro, MD Naples 3.9 30 117 4.4 32 141 4.6 67 308 566
37 483 Joseph Mazza, MD Fort Myers 4.0 4 16 4.3 35 151 3.8 10 38 4.8 58 278 483
38 185 John D. Ritrosky, MD Fort Myers 3.5 26 91 4.7 14 66 3.1 9 28 185
→ Entire Table Scrolls Right to Show Details. →
Plastic Surgeons with Some Ratings Below 3 (Out of 5 Stars)
Rank Total score Plastic Surgeon Office Location Vitals Healthgrades Realself Google Grand Total
Score # Total Score # Total Score # Total Score # Total
39 1782 Ralph R. Garramone, MD Fort Myers 3.9 19 74 2.9 36 104 4.8 98 470 4.8 236 1133 1782
40 556 Orlando Cicilioni, MD Sarasota 3.5 82 287 3.8 54 205 3.0 3 9 2.9 19 55 556
41 183 Rebecca L. Crane, MD Naples 4.8 16 77 5.0 19 95 5.0 2 10 1.0 1 1 183
42 147 Robert V. Mandraccia, MD Fort Myers 2.5 19 48 3.2 6 19 4.7 7 33 4.3 11 47 147
43 31 William O. Murtagh, MD Bonita Springs 2.8 11 31 31
See the ratings of Plastic Surgeons in other locations.
Dr looking down at camera
Face wrap
Fruit Aug
Rhino draped postop
Aug
Surgeon with knife

How to Read the Tables

SCORE: The "score" column for each review site lists the average score assigned to that doctor by the people who posted ratings on that review website. Each site uses a scale from 1-5, with 5 being the highest rating possible.

BOX COLOR REFLECTS THE AVERAGE SCORE:
  • Green Boxes: Average Score is between 4-5
  • Yellow Boxes: Average Score is between 3.0-3.9
  • Red Boxes: Average Score is between 1.0-2.9
  • Clear Boxes: When there is no score to report for this doctor on this review site, the box remains blank

#: The "#" column lists the number of reviewers who posted ratings and reviews for each doctor on each review site.

TOTAL: The "Total" column is the product of the score and the number of reviewers.

GRAND TOTAL: The "Grand Total" column is the sum of the "Total" scores from each review site. Plastic surgeons are listed in order of their Grand Total Scores, from highest to lowest, within each section.

GRAND TOTAL BOX COLOR:
  • GREEN Grand Total Boxes: Grand Total Boxes are colored GREEN when the doctor received average scores of 4.0 or higher from each of the ratings sites that reported ratings for the doctor.
  • YELLOW Grand Total Boxes: Grand Total Boxes are colored YELLOW when the doctor received an average score of 3.0-3.9 from at least one of the ratings sites.
  • RED Grand Total Boxes: Grand Total Boxes are colored RED when the doctor received an average score of 1.0 to 2.9 from at least one of the ratings sites.

SECTIONS: Plastic surgeons were divided into three sections, based upon their Grand Total Box color:

  • GREEN Section: The plastic surgeons who received average ratings of 4.0 or higher from all source sites appear in the green section and are ranked from highest to lowest Grand Total within that section.
  • YELLOW Section: The plastic surgeons who received one or more average score of 3.0-3.9 appear in the yellow section and are ranked from highest to lowest Grand Total within that section.
  • RED Section: The plastic surgeons who received one or more average score below 3.0 appear in the red section and are ranked from highest to lowest Grand Total within that section.

EMPTY BOXES: Empty white boxes indicate that we were unable to find ratings for that doctor on that ratings site. There could be many reasons for this including that the ratings site used a different spelling or location for the doctor than the ones that the American Board of Plastic Surgery used; it could mean things, none of which would suggest that there is something wrong with the doctor. As such, empty boxes neither count for nor against a doctors' score on Top Plastic Surgeon Reviews.

Abd-prepost wide
Open rhino
Dermaplane
Lipo infusion
Dermaplane
Abd incision

Things to Make Note of as You Review the Tables

Plastic Surgeons on this Site: This website includes plastic surgeons who are certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery. Doctors who perform plastic surgery but who are not certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery are not included on this site. Top Plastic Surgeon Reviews uses ABPS's website to determine which plastic surgeons are certified by ABPS (vs certified by another board) and which plastic surgeons are active (vs retired). With regard to the latter, ABPS' website is not infallible, so we sometimes include plastic surgeons who are retired, but who are still listed as active by ABPS. Evidently, retiring plastic surgeons routinely fail to notify the ABPS (as well as the ratings websites) that they have retired, so their inclusion on this site is inevitable unless we are informed otherwise. If you are aware that any of the plastic surgeons listed above have retired, then please let us know so that we may update our database.

Ratings Sites: There are sites beyond those listed here which provide physician reviews, but not all review sites could be included for practical reasons. The plastic surgery review sites which, in the opinion of TopPlasticSurgeonReviews.com, are the most popular and most pertinent were selected for this website. We have observed that the ratings and reviews for most plastic surgeons tend to be consistent across all ratings sites, so inclusion of additional sites would not likely change the ratings for most plastic surgeons in a significant way.

Few Ratings: Keep in mind that if a doctor has few ratings, this does not mean that the doctor is not a competent plastic surgeon. It may mean that the doctor does not perform as much surgery as the other doctors, or that the doctor has not been in practice as long, or that the doctor patients do not typically write online reviews, or a variety of other reasons.

Low Ratings: If a doctor has received ratings that placed the doctor in the yellow or red section, this also does not mean that s/he is not a good plastic surgeon. All it means is that they have one or more unfavorable ratings. And there are many reasons why good doctors can sometimes have unfavorable ratings including the following: 1) A complication or bad result (all plastic surgeons have them) which caused a patient to write one or more bad reviews. This may not mean that the doctor did anything wrong, even though the patient thought so. In other words, the same complications could have occurred no matter which plastic surgeon operated on the patient who wrote the unfavorable review(s). 2) Bad reviews placed fraudulently by someone wishing to damage the plastic surgeon's reputation (yes, this happens). In these cases, the plastic surgeon typically has little recourse with the ratings site, and they cannot do anything about it. 3) Misplaced ratings: There are cases in which a patient unintentionally rated the wrong doctor due to commonality of one doctor's name with another's. These situations are most obvious when the patient includes details of care indicating that the care was in a specialty different than that of the doctor who received the rating. 4) Occasionally, a doctor receives a glowing review and only one out of five stars from the patient who wrote the review. In these cases, the patient might have been thinking "#1" for "first place," but no one will ever know. In these situations the doctor's average score is pulled down by the rating, even though it should have been raised by receiving a high rating. There are many reasons why a low score does not necessarily correlate with the care that a doctor delivers. This is why visitors to this site should not attempt to read anything into a low score. Visitors should instead use this site as a gateway to the source sites (Vitals.com, Healthgrades.com, Realself.com, and Google.com) to see the ratings and read all of the reviews themselves. By visiting the source sites, a visitor will much more easily be able to interpret the validity of all scores.

Copyright 2016-present
TopPlasticSurgeonReviews.com

HOME LOCATIONS ABOUT US